| Proprietor | Date | Location* |
|---|
| Ackers, William (and Henry K. Hancock) | 1817 | e |
| Andem, Moses (and Hezekiah S. Kendall) | 1836 | o |
| Aspinwall (and Tappan) | 1819 | g |
| Boylston, Zabdiel | | y |
| Coolidge (and Griggs) | 1782 | w |
| Corey, Timothy | 1808 | q |
| Craft, Caleb | 1824 | i |
| Croft, Samuel | 1814 | v |
| Davis, Ebenezer (and Joseph White) | 1773 | z |
| Gardner, Thomas | | u |
| Goddard, Joseph and Benjamin | 1808 | p |
| Griggs (and Coolidge) | 1782 | w |
| Hammond, Jonathan | 1817 | c |
| Hancock, Henry K. (and William Ackers) | 1817 | e |
| Heath, Ebenezer | 1825 | j |
| Holden, James (and Jonas Tolman) | | a |
| Jackson, Jonathan | 1823 | h |
| Kendall, Hezekiah S. (and Moses Andem) | 1836 | o |
| Murdock, Nathaniel | 1817 | d |
| Penniman, Elisha | 1832 | l |
| Perry, Daniel (and John Warren) | 1838 | n |
| Pierce, John (and John Robinson) | | t |
| Receiving Tomb | 1864 | s |
| Richards, Ebenezer | 1817 | f |
| Robinson, John (and John Pierce) | | t |
| Sewall, Henry (and Edward Kitchen Wolcott) | 1770 | r |
| Stearns, Charles | 1825 | k |
| Tappan (and Aspinwall) | 1819 | g |
| Tolman, Jonas (and James Holden) | | a |
| Unknown. Perhaps Benjamin and Sarah (Aspinwall) White | | m |
| Unknown | | x |
| Ward, J. H. | 1860 | b |
| Warren, John (and Daniel Perry) | 1838 | n |
| White, Joseph (and Ebenezer Davis) | 1773 | z |
| Wolcott, Edward Kitchen (and Henry Sewall) | 1770 | r |
